Derecho Report: BGE Surprised by ‘Freak Storm’
"It is important to note that no utility east of the Mississippi River could have anticipated the raw strength of this storm system," stated the BGE report.
UPDATED (2:12 p.m.)—The unpredictability of the June derecho was an important factor in the scope and length of power outages across service area of Baltimore Gas and Electric (BGE), according to a new report filed with the state.
BGE filed its Major Outage Event Report with the Public Service Commission on July 30 as is required by Maryland law after a "major outage event." The derecho, which hit on June 29, left more than three quarters of a million Maryland customers in the dark—62 percent of BGE’s customer base in Maryland.
More than 100,000 BGE customers in Anne Arundel County lost power in June in the days after the storm.
The investigation was initiated by a letter sent by Howard County Executive Ken Ulman and six other elected municipal heads, including Anne Arundel County Executive John Leopold. In it, they said BGE refused to give them specific outage information directly after the storm hit, and that the utility generally needed to improve its performance during severe weather events.
BGE stated in the report that it “had no prior warning that a significant operational storm would be impacting BGE’s service area until approximately 10:30 PM; no request for crews was made by BGE at this time.”
Furthermore, BGE said that other utility companies also did not expect the storm to be so severe.
“It is important to note that no utility east of the Mississippi River could have anticipated the raw strength of this storm system,” the report reads.
A head meteorologist at the National Weather Service (NWS) agreed.
“Forecasting convective storms … is one of the most difficult things to do,” according to Jim Lee, meteorologist in charge at the NWS in Sterling, WV.
On the morning of June 29, BGE scheduled calls with its weather service providers. According to the report, the two calls both yielded similar reports “low threat of thunderstorms for the evening, but not severe.”
A storm watch—which means conditions are favorable for a storm—was issued at 9:51 p.m. that day for Howard, Carroll, Baltimore, Harford and Anne Arundel counties. The goal at NWS is a 17-minute lead-time for severe thunderstorm watches.
"We want to be able to provide you 17 minutes," Lee said. "So that you can seek shelter, go outside and roll up the windows, put your deck furniture away and bring your kids inside.
“In this event we gave over 37 minutes of lead-time. From a forecasting standpoint, that’s very good.”
BGE noted in its report that it was not until about 10:30 p.m. that “the full strength and destructive nature of the storm was known.”
The utility had, the report said, taken steps earlier in the day to “pre-mobilize additional crews to respond to potential heat-related outages and what was anticipated to be normal thunderstom activity.”
But the derecho was not normal thunderstorm activity. It was, in the words of the report: “one of the most destructive storms in BGE’s nearly 200-year history.”
“It was a freak storm,” Lee said.
See more:
- Derecho Storm Left ‘Hurricane-Like Damage’
- POLL: Tell Us About Your Power Outage Experience
- WATCH: Devastating Derecho in Action
- VIDEO: BGE Works to Restore Power
- Attorney General Gets Reports of Price Gouging After Storm
- UPDATE: BGE Making Progress in Restoring Power
- UPDATE: Storm Leaves Power Outages, Fallen Trees in County
dexter
6:50 am on Saturday, August 4, 2012
I wonder what they could have done to make the power grid more stable before the storm.
W. L.
9:22 am on Saturday, August 4, 2012
Our power goes out in regular storms all the time (almost every storm). Our whole neighborhood has had generators for years. Wonder what their excuse is for that?
Don Risher
12:04 pm on Saturday, August 4, 2012
It was war, man/woman against nature! There was little time to mobilize response and logistical resources. Then everyone experienced "The Fog of War" that gray area when you determine what happened, how bad was it, what needs to be deployed and how long will it take to accomplish.
Then everybody wants real time updates of, when is my power going to come back on? It's not likely that it will ever be as good as everyone would like it to be.
Better to prepare you and your family for the next emergency situation. Everybody knows they should prepare but not enough folks do. I'm installing a whole house generator and getting ready for our up-coming hurricane season.
Don Risher
info@BelairEngineering
Tommy Warshaw III
11:38 am on Monday, August 6, 2012
The problem though Don is that BGE had the same terrible response when TS Irene came through last year, and they knew that was coming/had time to mobilize. Of all the places I have lived in the U.S., BGE has by far had the longest outages on average that I've ever experienced.
MAW
12:27 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012
What can be done? Remove all trees around power lines. When these power lines where installed - say 40 plus years ago. The trees were not as overgrown on the properties. Over the years, trees have grown, and BGE has to trim back these trees just to make them semi-safe. BGE needs to be allowed to further trim trees back that grow towards their infrastructure. It is going to get worse as neighborhoods get older and the vegetation grows and invades the space the infrastructure occupies.
Mike Pallett
2:23 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012
My biggest question is why hasn't BGE burried the lines in these problem areas? Certainly there is a higher initial cost in doing this. I would imagine that the savings in not having to maintain the lines free from plant growth would rapidly pay for this expenditure- considering how often my power supply is dropped!
Brian
2:32 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012
Everyone acts like BGE really cares if your power is on or not. They still get paid either way. So they walk the fine line of keeping the cost down for repair/replace of equipment and customer satisfaction.
McGibblets
2:44 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012
Everyone acts like they know what BGE cares about, especially as if BGE were one big giant person, rather than a collective group of individuals.
Further, most successful corporations do walk a fine line between over/under investment in their company/product and the return on customer satisfaction. That is how they guage if they are running a successful business.
Patrick Mondor
2:56 pm on Monday, August 6, 2012
BGE stinks! They just requested an increase in delivery rates that could increase our bills another $11-12 per month. We pay some of the highest energy costs in the nations with some of the worst response times! I was without power for 6 days in Annapolis in 2003 due to Hurricane Isabel, moved to SP in 2005 and have lost power for over 7 days due to this and that storm, with a loss of power for almost 3 days this past storm. Each time BGE says they are blind sided. The only thing the company appears to do well is garner rate increases as it pleases and pay nice bonuses to its executives!